PMMM: Another Wish

Hello! This is my first story of the kind. It's a fanfiction of Puella Magi Madoka Magica, taking off from is Madoka picked a sort of different wish to make in order to fix this. Taking place in a time loop where everyone is still alive, but only Homura and Madoka know the truth about what's happening. Sorry to say though it probably won't be a happy ending for most of the girls (well, look at the canon) and that there won't be any penetrative or obvious to the call sex.

Title: Another Wish

Fandom: Puella Magi Madoka Magica

Contains: Girl to Futa to Boy, suicide, body shaming, sexual experimentation, magic, homosexuality. (Will update as needed)

Homura told her the truth- everything about the Kyubey and all the time lines she had been through. Madoka spent the rest of the night crying on her bed and watching as the Kyubey sat down and stared at her with the blank expression. Mami and the others didn’t know yet. Homura wouldn’t tell her (she said it ended badly that time and after all that what could be considered bad?) so she was here, alone with her thoughts.

“I know, but do you have to be so cruel about it!?” All the explanations and justifications didn’t mean much. Could the world really grow on the sufferings of others? Madoka bit her lip and looked at the little alien, content with one thing. Even if she messed up again and again, Homura would be able to try again…and then maybe she could help her smile, by the end.

“Kyubey, I have my wish.” He tilted his head to the side.

“What would that be, Madoka?”

“I wish…that after making a wish, we can no longer be magical girls.” Little ribbons went in front of her to make the soul gem and Kyubey’s red eyes looked at her before everything went black.

A soft paw and the morning’s sunlight is what woke her up the next day.

“That was an interesting wish, Madoka.” Madoka woke up from the floor next to her bed feeling dizzy and weak. On her chest was the soul gem she had seen. Greif piled up inside of her at the thought of her failed task.

“It didn’t work…”

“Oh, It worked more than you think, Madoka-kun. You and the others are no longer magical girls. I don’t even know if you’re powers are there. I can confirm that you won’t become Witches now.” She was blindsided by what he said and looked down at herself thoroughly. He left saying he was going to check out some information.

Everything on her appeared the same- her hair, her eyes, the little mounds that where finally starting to show on her breasts- but between her legs with a penis and testicles like boys had. It was already the size of her middle finger. She wasn’t a girl anymore.

“Madoka-chan! Sayaka’s on the phone for you and she seems worried. Did she forget her homework again?” Her dad called from outside the room, leaving the phone